Marriage & the Amendment

Constitutional Ban on Gay Unions in Ohio Threatens Domestic Violence Safeguards; Other States Also See Broad Impact

Overview

For Immediate Release: January 19, 2005

Madison — States that passed constitutional amendments banning gay unions last year are discovering that such bans have consequences far beyond defining marriage. In the latest example, a public defender in Ohio has asked a judge to dismiss domestic violence charges against unmarried defendants, arguing that the Ohio amendment prohibits him from giving unmarried couples protections granted to married couples.

Backers of a similar constitutional amendment in Wisconsin claim it would not ban civil unions and would not endanger particular benefits for gay couples, despite the clear language to the contrary in the amendment and mounting evidence of far-reaching consequences in other states.

“What is happening in Ohio and other states could happen in Wisconsin if we pass this amendment,” said Action Wisconsin executive director Christopher Ott. “The backers of the Wisconsin amendment don’t want to ‘define marriage.’ They want to deny gay couples–and for that matter, all unmarried couples–the rights, protections, and responsibilities of marriage. Even for people who oppose marriage for gay couples, this amendment goes too far.”

The Wisconsin amendment would define marriage as “one man and one woman” and prohibit any legal status that is “substantially similar” to marriage. It must be passed a second time by the Legislature and then be approved by voters. The Legislature could take up the amendment any day.

Ways that constitutional bans on gay unions are being used to deny protections in other states:

Utah – In a lawsuit, a man is claiming the constitutional amendment there invalidates a restraining order taken out against him by his ex-girlfriend.
(Link to source.)

Ohio – The public defender in Cuyahoga County (Cleveland) is asking a judge to dismiss domestic violence charges against unmarried defendants.
(Link to source.)

Ohio – The University of Toledo announced it cannot offer domestic partner benefits to its employees.
(Link to source.)

Michigan – Governor Jennifer Granholm ordered domestic partner benefits to be removed from contracts that were being negotiated for state workers.
(Link to source.)

Action Wisconsin is planning a statewide lobby day against the amendment for Thursday, January 27th.

CONTACT: Joshua Freker, 608.441.0143 x304

From the archive

This article was first published by Action Wisconsin on January 19, 2005. It is part of the restored archive of actionwisconsin.org, so names, phone numbers, events and calls to action in it date from that time.

More from the newsroom

Browse the full Action Wisconsin newsroom, or read more coverage in Marriage & the Amendment.