Marriage & the Amendment

Judge Rules Ban on Gay Unions Kills Domestic Violence Safeguards for Unmarried People

Overview

For Immediate Release: March 24, 2005

Madison – Yesterday, an Ohio judge ruled that domestic violence charges cannot be filed against unmarried people because of Ohio’s recently enacted constitutional ban on civil unions and marriage for gay couples. Action Wisconsin decried the potential far-reaching consequences of the similar ban being proposed in Wisconsin.

“The evidence is piling up that these bans on gay unions do much more than ‘define marriage,'” said Action Wisconsin executive director Christopher Ott. “The effects of these bans are not abstract. In real terms, they mean people–gay and non-gay alike–are denied bereavement leave, lose their health care, and potentially lose the right to be safe from domestic violence. For any reasonable person, these bans simply go too far.”

In the Ohio case, a Cleveland man was accused of physically harming his live-in girlfriend in January. The man’s lawyer had asked the judge to throw out the domestic violence charge because of the new wording in Ohio’s constitution. In his ruling, the judge said he had no choice but to throw out domestic violence in favor of the lesser charge because the domestic violence law conflicts with the state constitution.

There are now 17 states with constitutional bans on gay unions, and several are experiencing far-reaching consequences. Last week, Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox ruled that cities like Kalamazoo cannot renew future employee contracts that include domestic partner health insurance policies. This ruling could take away existing health benefits for public employees.

The Michigan ruling echoes the predictions of Madison City Attorney Michael May. May recently issued a legal opinion saying that the proposed Wisconsin amendment would likely invalidate Madison’s domestic partner benefits policy.

“Too many Wisconsin lawmakers continue to support the proposed amendment here, despite the mounting evidence that it could have all sorts of far-reaching consequences for Wisconsin families,” said Ott. “But we remain hopeful that more and more Wisconsinites will see that the proposed amendment will hurt real families by denying critical protections that come with civil marriage.”

Link to Ohio story
Link to column about Michigan Attorney General ruling.

From the archive

This article was first published by Action Wisconsin on March 24, 2005. It is part of the restored archive of actionwisconsin.org, so names, phone numbers, events and calls to action in it date from that time.

More from the newsroom

Browse the full Action Wisconsin newsroom, or read more coverage in Marriage & the Amendment.