Legal Guide, Part 2

The Rights of LGBT People in Wisconsin…

What Does the Law Say?

State Laws

In the Workplace
You cannot legally be fired, demoted, denied a job, or otherwise treated unequally on the job because of your sexual orientation. The law covers all employers, including labor unions, employment agencies, and licensing agencies. Workplace harassment based on sexual orientation is also illegal. This means, for example, if co-workers harass someone for being gay, supervisors have a duty to try to stop that harassment.

Under Wisconsin law, harassment may include verbal abuse, epithets, vulgar or derogatory language, display of offensive cartoons or materials, mimicry, lewd or offensive gestures, and telling jokes offensive to lesbians, gay men, and/or bisexuals. The behavior must be more than a few isolated incidents or casual comments. Harassment involves a pattern of abusive and degrading conduct directed against the employee based on sexual orientation that is sufficient to interfere with his or her work or to create an offensive and hostile work environment.

Religious institutions are sometimes exempt from the law when hiring for a religion-based position. In order to be exempt, the job description must demonstrate that the position is clearly related to the religious teachings and beliefs of the institution. In other words, it’s likely a church with consistent anti-gay religious beliefs could discriminate against a lesbian applying to be a minister but could not discriminate against a lesbian applying to be a janitor.

State courts have said that it is not an illegal form of workplace discrimination for an employer to refuse to provide domestic partner benefits to lesbian, gay, and bisexual employees and their same-sex partners.

In Housing
It is illegal to be kicked out of your home; threatened or intimidated; denied the ability to rent, buy, construct, or finance a home; or otherwise be treated unequally in housing because of your sexual orientation. The law applies to management companies, landlords, real estate agents, and subsidized housing. The law does not apply to roommates in units in which five or fewer people live.

In Public Accommodations
It is illegal to be kicked out of, denied services from, or otherwise treated differently by a place of public accommodation because of your sexual orientation. Wisconsin law considers public accommodations to include places of business or recreation, lodging establishments, credit/financial services, restaurants, taverns, nursing homes, clinics, hospitals, and any other place where accommodations, amusement, goods, or services are available to the general public. Private, nonprofit organizations that provide accommodations, amusement, goods, and services only to their members and members’ guests (for example, country clubs) are not considered public accommodations under state law.

The law also forbids anti-gay harassment in public accommodations, so long as the employees or owners have some degree of control over the harassment. For example, it may be illegal discrimination if a bartender is loudly talking with a patron about how he hates “faggots” and “dykes.”

Sexual orientation discrimination in public accommodations can also include discrimination against same-sex couples who show each other affection in the same way that opposite-sex couples do in the same establishment. For example, you cannot be kicked off a bus or out of a store for holding hands with your partner, or for slow-dancing with your partner in a bar where heterosexual couples dance together all the time.

Local Laws

A handful of local governments also ban sexual orientation discrimination. Although state law already bans such discrimination, local laws reinforce the message to area employers, landlords, and public accommodations that anti-gay discrimination is unacceptable. Local civil rights laws can provide additional ways (other than under state law) to seek help if you experience discrimination. Many towns and cities have agencies designed to enforce these laws, providing complaint and investigation procedures similar to the state Equal Rights Division process. (See next page for more details on how to file a complaint either through the state agency or a local agency.)

In some cases, local law can be stronger than state law. For example, a growing number of cities, towns, and counties across the country are passing protections for transgender people. Currently, Madison and Dane County are the only Wisconsin jurisdictions that specifically ban gender identity discrimination.

NEXT: What to Do if You Experience Discrimination

You can jump to these sections:

Introduction

What to Do if You Experience Discrimination?

Resources

CAN YOU SUPPORT OUR WORK?

You can make a contribution online to Action Wisconsin. Your help will support the development of legal guides like this one, as well as other resources we’re preparing for Wisconsin’s LGBT community.

DISCLAIMER

This resource is designed to educate people generally about the law, but it is not legal advice. If legal advice is needed, contact an attorney (see Resources).

Transgender people are not yet explicitly protected against discrimination under state law. It is possible that anti-transgender discrimination is illegal under the state’s sex discrimination law, but Wisconsin courts have not yet considered this issue. Action Wisconsin supports efforts to make it clear that anti-transgender discrimination is illegal by explicitly banning gender identity discrimination in existing state and local civil rights laws.

These local jurisdictions ban the following:

Dane County — sexual orientation and gender identity discrimination in housing, county government (public) employment, and for companies that contract with the county.

Madison — sexual orientation and gender identity discrimination in private and public employment, housing, and public accommodations.

Milwaukee — sexual orientation discrimination in private and public employment, housing, and some public accommodations (companies that need city licenses to operate).

Shorewood Hills — sexual orientation discrimination in public employment.

Winnebago County — sexual orientation discrimination in public employment.

This may not be a complete list of every jurisdiction that bans sexual orientation discrimination.